Tea Drinkers to Share $2.5M Settlement Over False ‘Made in USA’ Claims

California buyers of nine Bigelow tea varieties can claim 50 cents per box after a jury found leaves came from India and Sri Lanka

Christen da Costa Avatar
Christen da Costa Avatar

By

Our team of chefs and seasoned travelers delivers honest, expertly crafted insights to guide your dining and travel experiences. While our expertise drives the process, we use AI to ensure our content is succinct and engaging.

Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.

Image: Bigelow Tea

Key Takeaways

  • Federal jury awarded $2.5M after finding Bigelow’s “Made in USA” tea label misled buyers.
  • Bigelow’s tea leaves originated from India and Sri Lanka, comprising over 90% of each product.
  • California buyers of nine qualifying Bigelow varieties can claim up to $20 before February 2027.

The tea inside was grown in India and Sri Lanka. The box said “Manufactured in the USA 100% American Family Owned.” In April 2025, a federal jury in the Central District of California ruled against R.C. Bigelow, Inc. in Banks v. R.C. Bigelow, Inc., finding the Connecticut-based tea company violated California’s Consumer Legal Remedies Act, breached an express warranty, and made a false representation — and awarded $2,360,744 to the class. For California shoppers who bought qualifying boxes during a nearly six-year window, that verdict translates into real money, with a claim deadline of Feb. 8, 2027.

What the Label Said vs. What Was in the Box

The gap between Bigelow’s domestic blending operation and the foreign origin of its tea leaves was at the center of the dispute.

Bigelow argued that its tea was blended and packaged in the United States — a real but narrow distinction. The complaint countered that the tea leaves themselves, sourced from India and Sri Lanka, represented more than 90% of each covered product and were never grown or processed on American soil. The jury sided with the plaintiffs. With post-judgment interest added, the class payment pool now stands at $2,548,187. Bigelow’s total settlement obligation — covering legal fees, administration costs, and service awards — is reportedly capped at $6.5 million. The company denies wrongdoing and agreed to resolve the case to avoid continued litigation costs and risk. This kind of misleading product labeling has drawn scrutiny across consumer goods categories.

Nine varieties are covered:

  • Earl Grey
  • Green Tea
  • Constant Comment
  • Green Lemon
  • Vanilla Chai
  • English Tea Time
  • Spiced Chai
  • French Vanilla
  • Vanilla Caramel Black Tea

All in 18- or 20-count boxes labeled “Manufactured in the USA 100% American Family Owned.”

Do You Qualify? Here’s What to Check

Eligibility hinges on where, when, and which box you bought.

  • Purchase must be from a California retail store between Oct. 17, 2017, and July 31, 2023
  • Must be an 18- or 20-count box carrying the “Manufactured in the USA 100% American Family Owned” label
  • Payout is 50 cents per qualifying box; capped at up to $10 per household without proof of purchase, or up to $20 with a receipt, receipt copy, or paid invoice
  • Claim deadline: Feb. 8, 2027 (online or by mail)
  • Opt-out or objection deadline: Jan. 7, 2027; final approval hearing: May 17, 2027

Note that actual payment amounts may be adjusted depending on the total number of valid claims filed and the terms of the final settlement approval. Shoppers wary of retail pricing practices may also want to know that stores sometimes overcharge at the register, according to inspector findings.

For anyone who bought a qualifying box, fifty cents per purchase adds up — and even without a receipt, claimants may recover up to $10. Keep that old receipt and that figure doubles. The Feb. 8 deadline leaves shoppers plenty of time to check the pantry and file.

OUR Editorial Process

Every travel tip, dining recommendation, and review is powered by real human research. See our Code of Ethics here →



Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.