Erewhon’s $749 Thanksgiving Dinner Doesn’t Include Cranberry Sauce

Erewhon’s fully cooked holiday package for 10 tops $900 with sides, while Aldi feeds the same crowd for under $39

Rex Freiberger Avatar
Rex Freiberger Avatar

By

Our team of chefs and seasoned travelers delivers honest, expertly crafted insights to guide your dining and travel experiences. While our expertise drives the process, we use AI to ensure our content is succinct and engaging.

Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.

Image: Erewhon

Key Takeaways

  • Erewhon’s $749 “Ultimate Organic Feast” excludes cranberry sauce, adding $29 more.
  • Aldi offers a complete Thanksgiving for 10 people under $39, cranberries included.
  • Only 51% of Americans plan to host Thanksgiving in 2026, down from 59%.

For $749, Erewhon will deliver a cooked Thanksgiving dinner to your door. The package covers turkey, stuffing, garlic mashed potatoes, Brussels sprouts, rainbow carrots, gravy, and pumpkin pie — fully prepared for eight to ten people. What it does not cover: cranberry sauce. That costs another $29, sold separately.

A LendingTree survey found that Americans considering hosting Thanksgiving in 2026 expected to spend an average of $427 on food, drinks, and housewares combined. Erewhon’s base package clears that figure before a single additional side dish enters the picture.

What $749 Buys at Erewhon – and What It Doesn’t

The “Ultimate Organic Feast” arrives cooked and ready, except for a few classics that will cost extra.

  • Base package: $749, serves 8–10
  • Cranberry sauce: $29 per 16 oz, sold separately
  • Green beans or mac and cheese: $55 each
  • Fully loaded with additional sides: reported above $900, before delivery fees
  • Smaller options: $439 (4–6 people); vegan version at $340 (4–6 people)

The Number That Puts $749 in Perspective

Aldi is advertising a full Thanksgiving for 10 people at under $4 per head — cranberries included.

Aldi’s advertised Thanksgiving package covers ingredients for 10: a 16-pound turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes, rolls, cranberries, peas, carrots, celery, pumpkin-pie ingredients, milk, and whipping cream — all for under $39. “We want to make sure everyone can enjoy a Thanksgiving meal for 10 for under $39, no coupons or special requirements needed,” Aldi CEO Atty McGrath said.

These are not the same product. Aldi sells raw ingredients that still require cooking and preparation. Erewhon sells a finished, cooked meal, along with the branding and the particular social signal of serving guests something that arrives in an Erewhon box — the culinary equivalent of leaving a designer bag on the counter where company can see it. For a sense of the comfort food traditions that anchor most Thanksgiving tables, the contrast with Erewhon’s offer is striking.

That signal costs money. Whether it’s worth it depends entirely on what a host is actually buying. Meanwhile, only 51% of Americans said they were considering hosting Thanksgiving in 2026, down from 59% the year prior, per LendingTree. That dip in hosting intent may say less about Thanksgiving itself and more about who, exactly, a $749 dinner is designed for.

The Cranberry Sauce Is the Story

A $29 upcharge for one of the holiday’s most familiar staples reveals exactly what this offering is — and isn’t.

Erewhon’s package is not a complete Thanksgiving in the traditional sense. It is a cooked, delivered, carefully assembled meal — premium in sourcing and presentation. The cranberry sauce that many hosts treat as non-negotiable runs $29 extra. That single detail captures what the “Ultimate Organic Feast” represents: a Thanksgiving built for convenience and cachet, sold at a price that reflects both — much like the kind of hidden fee that has sparked broader conversations about transparency in food pricing.

OUR Editorial Process

Every travel tip, dining recommendation, and review is powered by real human research. See our Code of Ethics here →



Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.