For $749, Erewhon will deliver a cooked Thanksgiving dinner to your door. The package covers turkey, stuffing, garlic mashed potatoes, Brussels sprouts, rainbow carrots, gravy, and pumpkin pie — fully prepared for eight to ten people. What it does not cover: cranberry sauce. That costs another $29, sold separately.
A LendingTree survey found that Americans considering hosting Thanksgiving in 2026 expected to spend an average of $427 on food, drinks, and housewares combined. Erewhon’s base package clears that figure before a single additional side dish enters the picture.
What $749 Buys at Erewhon – and What It Doesn’t
The “Ultimate Organic Feast” arrives cooked and ready, except for a few classics that will cost extra.
- Base package: $749, serves 8–10
- Cranberry sauce: $29 per 16 oz, sold separately
- Green beans or mac and cheese: $55 each
- Fully loaded with additional sides: reported above $900, before delivery fees
- Smaller options: $439 (4–6 people); vegan version at $340 (4–6 people)
The Number That Puts $749 in Perspective
Aldi is advertising a full Thanksgiving for 10 people at under $4 per head — cranberries included.
Aldi’s advertised Thanksgiving package covers ingredients for 10: a 16-pound turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes, rolls, cranberries, peas, carrots, celery, pumpkin-pie ingredients, milk, and whipping cream — all for under $39. “We want to make sure everyone can enjoy a Thanksgiving meal for 10 for under $39, no coupons or special requirements needed,” Aldi CEO Atty McGrath said.
These are not the same product. Aldi sells raw ingredients that still require cooking and preparation. Erewhon sells a finished, cooked meal, along with the branding and the particular social signal of serving guests something that arrives in an Erewhon box — the culinary equivalent of leaving a designer bag on the counter where company can see it. For a sense of the comfort food traditions that anchor most Thanksgiving tables, the contrast with Erewhon’s offer is striking.
That signal costs money. Whether it’s worth it depends entirely on what a host is actually buying. Meanwhile, only 51% of Americans said they were considering hosting Thanksgiving in 2026, down from 59% the year prior, per LendingTree. That dip in hosting intent may say less about Thanksgiving itself and more about who, exactly, a $749 dinner is designed for.
The Cranberry Sauce Is the Story
A $29 upcharge for one of the holiday’s most familiar staples reveals exactly what this offering is — and isn’t.
Erewhon’s package is not a complete Thanksgiving in the traditional sense. It is a cooked, delivered, carefully assembled meal — premium in sourcing and presentation. The cranberry sauce that many hosts treat as non-negotiable runs $29 extra. That single detail captures what the “Ultimate Organic Feast” represents: a Thanksgiving built for convenience and cachet, sold at a price that reflects both — much like the kind of hidden fee that has sparked broader conversations about transparency in food pricing.


















