A 1950s Pensacola Motor Lodge Reborn as Hotel Margot

Two local entrepreneurs converted a 1950s Pensacola motor lodge into a 45-room boutique hotel for $2 million, anchored by a public café and courtyard bar

Annemarije De Boer Avatar
Annemarije De Boer Avatar

By

Our team of chefs and seasoned travelers delivers honest, expertly crafted insights to guide your dining and travel experiences. While our expertise drives the process, we use AI to ensure our content is succinct and engaging.

Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.

Image: Caleb Pierce/Hotel Margot

Key Takeaways

  • Local entrepreneurs redeveloped a 1950s Pensacola motor lodge into a 45-room boutique hotel for $2 million.
  • Designer Lauren Bakarian-Simpson applied quiet maximalism, blending Palm Beach motifs with midcentury Florida architecture.
  • Colette Café serves cardamom buns and espresso to both guests and locals, anchoring Hotel Margot in downtown Pensacola.

Whatever the Solé Inn and Suites was selling in the 1950s, Schumacher wallpaper and cardamom buns weren’t part of the pitch. That former motor lodge on Palafox Street is now Hotel Margot — a 45-room boutique property that local entrepreneurs Rafael Simpson and Graham Guirl redeveloped for a reported $2 million. Designer Lauren Bakarian-Simpson of Haus of Hue handled the interiors. For travelers who assumed Pensacola meant beach-or-bust, this downtown conversion suggests a more interesting option.

Image: Caleb Pierce/Hotel Margot

Quiet Maximalism, Coral Pink, and a Shell-Encrusted Mirror

The design punches well above a 235–280 square-foot footprint, layering Palm Beach motifs over midcentury Florida bones.

Bakarian-Simpson’s aesthetic lands somewhere between Palm Beach fever dream and midcentury Florida nostalgia — a sensibility the design world describes as “quiet maximalism.” The interiors include:

  • A shell-encrusted vintage mirror
  • Retro breeze-block pillars the original building contributed for free
  • Bullion-fringed seating
  • Moroccan zellige tile
  • Brass fixtures
  • Tropical upholstery on custom furniture
  • Vintage-inspired mini fridges that look like they were sourced from a very stylish estate sale

The building kept its three-story structure; the interiors gave those bones a personality worth photographing.

Image: Caleb Pierce/Hotel Margot

The Café That Earns the Hotel’s Keep

Colette is built for the neighborhood, not just for checkout-morning crowds.

Blue-and-white Delft tile, street-facing seats, and morning light. The pastry case holds seasonal scones, quiche Lorraine, cardamom buns, and pains au chocolat alongside proper espresso drinks. Colette Café is counter-service and open to the public — the hotel explicitly describes it as a neighborhood gathering point, welcoming locals and guests alike.

According to Travel + Leisure, the café’s pastry program and espresso drinks rank among the property’s sharpest offerings. A hotel café this considered rarely stays a secret for long.

The courtyard pool makes a different argument entirely. Coral-pink lounge chairs, tasseled umbrellas, bougainvillea, and Mediterranean-influenced landscaping give it the atmosphere of a private club rather than a standard hotel amenity. The Coral Bar, built around an Alabama marble bar, anchors the afternoon with handcrafted cocktails. Pensacola Beach sits approximately eight miles away — a day trip, not a commute.

Image: Caleb Pierce/Hotel Margot

Downtown Pensacola Is Actually the Point

Complimentary bikes and a house Moke aren’t gimmicks — they’re the right tools for this neighborhood.

Palafox Market sets up in the linear park adjacent to the hotel on weekends. Independent restaurants, bars, shops, and live events fill the walkable historic district around it. According to Travel + Leisure, the hotel’s downtown positioning gives guests access to a side of Pensacola that most beachfront visitors never reach. Complimentary beach cruisers and a house Moke are on hand because the neighborhood genuinely rewards exploration.

Hotel Margot works best when Pensacola Beach is treated as an option rather than the obligation. Reported rates start at approximately $220 per night for double occupancy at the time of Travel + Leisure‘s review; confirm current pricing and availability directly at hotelmargot.com.

OUR Editorial Process

Every travel tip, dining recommendation, and review is powered by real human research. See our Code of Ethics here →



Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.