The Best Supermarket Pumpkin Pies for Thanksgiving: From $5.99 to $14

Costco, Trader Joe’s, Wegmans, and Whole Foods pies compared on price, size, spice, and ingredients

Christen da Costa Avatar
Christen da Costa Avatar

By

Our team of chefs and seasoned travelers delivers honest, expertly crafted insights to guide your dining and travel experiences. While our expertise drives the process, we use AI to ensure our content is succinct and engaging.

Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.

Image: PICRYL

Key Takeaways

  • Costco’s 58-ounce Kirkland pumpkin pie delivers roughly 50 cents per slice at $5.99.
  • Whole Foods offers the only reportedly fresh-baked pie, free of preservatives and hydrogenated fats.
  • Wegmans provides a gluten-free pumpkin pie option, giving it a practical edge over competitors.

Three days before Thanksgiving, the custard cracks, the crust burns, and suddenly a store-bought pie sounds like the smartest decision you’ve made all month — the kind of comfort food move that keeps holiday gatherings running smoothly. Four grocery chains — Costco, Trader Joe’s, Wegmans, and Whole Foods — each solve the problem differently, with prices reported in a range from $5.99 to $14, though costs vary by location and date. Your table size, spice tolerance, and ingredient priorities should drive the call. Here’s what each option actually delivers.

Big Table, Small Budget: Costco and Trader Joe’s

Two wallet-friendly pies at opposite ends of the size spectrum.

Costco’s Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie is hard to beat on volume: reportedly 58 ounces, 12 inches across, and $5.99 at warehouse locations — roughly 50 cents a slice when cut into 12 servings. The filling is said to use Dickinson pumpkins, a variety associated with smooth, sweet purée, though secondary tasting coverage consistently notes a restrained spice profile. A Costco membership is required for warehouse purchases, and holiday stock may move quickly.

Trader Joe’s takes a different approach. Its nine-inch, 25.39-ounce pie is listed at $6.99 and officially labeled limited-time. Trader Joe’s describes the filling as silky and custardy, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice — a noticeably bolder profile than Costco’s milder offering, according to available tasting reports. Smaller gatherings may also find Teeny Tiny Pumpkin Pies useful, though seasonal availability should be confirmed locally.

At a Glance: Four Pies, Four Priorities

StoreSizePriceNotes
Costco~58 oz~$5.99~50 cents per serving (based on 12 slices); mild spice, Dickinson pumpkin filling, membership required
Trader Joe’s25.39 oz$6.99Pronounced spice blend, confirmed limited-time seasonal item, smaller format options may be available
Wegmans30 oz~$10Heavy cream filling, cinnamon-sugar crust finish, gluten-free pie option available
Whole FoodsFull-size~$14Reportedly baked fresh in-store, real butter and unbleached flour crust, no hydrogenated fats, HFCS, or preservatives; half-pie available at select locations

The Middle Ground and the Premium Pick

Wegmans and Whole Foods serve different kinds of hosts.

Wegmans’ 30-ounce pie at around $10 earns its middle-ground reputation on ingredient detail. Heavy whipping cream enriches the filling — confirmed on the official product listing — and a cinnamon-sugar crust finish reportedly adds texture. For households navigating dietary restrictions, Wegmans lists a gluten-free pumpkin pie option, giving it a practical edge worth confirming with your local store before the holiday.

Whole Foods sits at the top of the price range at approximately $14, but it is also the only pie on this list reported to be baked fresh in-store. The crust is said to use real butter and unbleached flour, with no preservatives, hydrogenated fats, or high-fructose corn syrup — a far cry from the beloved treats of the past that were loaded with artificial ingredients. The filling reportedly includes pumpkin purée, sweetened condensed milk, cane sugar, eggs, and warming spices. Half-pie options exist at some locations — a sensible fit for a shorter guest list. All Whole Foods details should be confirmed directly, as no current official product page was available at time of writing.

Before You Head Out

A few details worth confirming before Thanksgiving morning.

Prices and availability vary by location — verify stock, allergen information, and dietary claims directly with your local store before purchasing. Trader Joe’s supply is seasonal and may become unavailable before the holiday. Costco requires a membership for warehouse purchases. For any pie that skews mild on spice, a spoonful of cinnamon whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream closes the gap without any extra baking.

OUR Editorial Process

Every travel tip, dining recommendation, and review is powered by real human research. See our Code of Ethics here →



Read our Code of Ethics to see how we maintain integrity in everything we do.